CONCERT REVIEW: SARAH JAROSZ BRINGS FOLK AND A TOUCH OF BLUEGRASS TO NASHUA CENTER FOR THE ARTS (11/14/26)

by Michael McCarthy

Saturday night, November 14th, 2026, I finally saw Sarah Jarosz for the second time. The first time I saw her she was opening for Josh Radin and A Fine Frenzy at the Boston Orpheum in 2007. I had never heard of Sarah Jarosz before that show but I was very much impressed watching her perform solo on stage that night and I have been a fan of her music ever since.

Sarah’s current tour is being centered around the 10th anniversary of her album Undercurrent, which won the best folk album Grammy in 2017. In total, Sarah has now won six Grammy Awards, “House of Mercy,” which is one of the songs on Undercurrent, also won the Grammy Award for best American roots performance. In 2020, Sarah won the Grammy for Best American Roots song for her song “Call My Name,” which is from I’m With Her, her trio with Aoife O’Donovan and Sara Watkins. In 2021, Sarah earned the Grammy for best Americana album for World on the Ground. And in 2026, she won two more Grammy Awards with I’m With Her, best contemporary folk album for Wild and Clear and Blue and best American roots song for “Ancient Light.”

Sarah Jarosz, photographed by Shervin Lainez.

Sarah began last night’s concert with a few songs from her other albums before she performed Undercurrent in its entirety, doing the songs in the exact order that they appear in on the album. the first song she did last night was one of my personal favorites, “Over The Edge,” which hails from her album Build Me Up From Bones from 2013, which is probably my favorite Sarah Jarosz album even though I enjoy all of her work.

Sarah performed most of last night’s songs with Jeff Picker on bass. But Picker isn’t merely Sarah’s bassist; he’s also her husband. The two of them performed most of last night’s songs together with Picker also providing backing vocals on a few songs. I found his bass playing to be exceptionally good. Seeing him perform, you could literally see how intricate the bass guitar parts on many of Sarah’s songs are. He played with his fingers and they were all over the place. I kind of felt like I was watching a magician pull off a complicated trick as I watched him play. Of course, Sarah’s guitar work was every bit as impressive. She played acoustic guitar on the next few songs, which were “When the Lights Go Out” and “The Way It Is Now” from the album Polaroid Lovers then “Early Morning Light,” the latter of which began the eleven songs from Undercurrent.

Sarah and Jeff told a few funny stories last night. Perhaps the most amusing one was that when Sarah’s song “When the Lights Go Out” debuted on Spotify, Jeff saw it among the newly released singles and the track that appeared directly below it was Billy Joel’s “Turn the Lights Back On,” so they joked that they “got Joeled,” which got quite a laugh from the crowd.

As much as I love the Undercurrent album, I have to say that I think I actually enjoyed those songs, hearing them live last night, even more than I do when I listen to the album. I think that was largely because I love a good bass guitar sound and the bass was much more audible during last night’s performance than it is on the Undercurrent album. Also, last night Sarah’s vocals were front and center at all times, whereas on the album the guitars are often just as loud as the vocals.

Jeff also remarked last night that when Undercurrent came out it was the first time that he and Sarah had worked together so the 10th anniversary of the album was also like the 10th anniversary of them being together. He joked, “We thought we’d celebrate by playing a bunch of songs about her ex-boyfriends.” Everyone laughed and seemed to think it was just a joke but then Sarah admitted that Undercurrent is definitely a “break up album.”

Another joke Jeff made was that most of Sarah’s songs sound like metal songs if you read the titles a certain way. To that end, he used a death metal sort of voice and said “House of Mercy” and “Everything to Hide” as examples. It was an amusing joke, but he actually did have a point. Speaking of metal, Sarah actually told us that she got really into Metallica during the pandemic. At first everyone laughed, assuming it was just a joke, but she was indeed serious and said that they’re really good. She also said that she and Jeff worked out their own arrangement of Metallica’s “Unforgiven II.” When she said that, several people shouted out that they should play it. Unfortunately, they explained that they couldn’t play it because they hadn’t memorized the lyrics; they were just reading the lyrics from their laptop when they were playing it at home.

Before performing “Jacqueline,” the final song from Undercurrent, she explained that she was living in New York at the time she was writing the album and she would often stop by the Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis Reservoir in Central Park. She explained that she always imagined that Jackie’s ghost was present when she was there and that inspired the song.

Next up was a cover of Dolly Parton’s “Marry Me.” Sarah said how lucky we were to live during a time that Dolly Parton was alive. Sarah said that she’d met Dolly twice and it was wonderful. Sarah said Dolly was, “as good as it gets.” And one of the reasons Sarah chose to perform “Marry Me” is that it isn’t just a song Dolly performed; it’s also one that Dolly herself wrote.

A very talented cat named Jefferson Hamer opened for Sarah last night and he joined Sarah and Jeff on stage to perform the last few songs of the show, “Blue Heron” from the album Blue Heron Suite, a cover of Bob Dylan’s “Ring Them Bells” and the encore, “Runaway Train” from the album Polaroid Lovers.

All in all, it was a terrific show and one of the things that made it so enjoyable was that Sarah and Jeff appeared to be having a really good time performing it. The one critique I would have about Sarah’s music in general is that it tends to be really serious but in concert the songs somehow felt a bit lighter and almost happier somehow. I would say that Sarah had something of a playful spirit last night so her darker songs didn’t seem quite so dark and I really enjoyed seeing her do those songs in a bit more of an upbeat mood than she tends to do them on the album.

Suffice to say, I highly recommend that you catch Sarah if you have the opportunity. If you’re not already a fan of her music, I would definitely suggest that you hop on whatever streaming service you subscribe to and check her out now. If you like folk, I would start with Undercurrent but if you prefer more melodic music then I would start with Polaroid Lovers.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *