CONCERT REVIEW: TAYLORVILLE DAZZLES AT NASHUA CENTER FOR THE ARTS (11/15/26)

by Michael McCarthy

(The photos appearing with this review are from other Taylorville shows and come courtesy of Sinead Angele.)

I’ve never seen Taylor Swift in concert, but after seeing Taylorville, a Taylor Swift tribute act from St. Louis, Missouri, at the Nashua Center for the Arts on Sunday, November 15th, I certainly want to. Featuring a remarkably convincing Taylor impersonator, a terrific four-piece band, elaborate costumes, and enough special effects to rival an arena concert, Taylorville delivered a thoroughly entertaining show that delighted both young Swifties and older fans like myself.

The fun actually began before the concert, when Taylor Swift trivia questions appeared on the large video screen behind the stage. Questions included which popular television series Taylor had appeared on and which album she’d released in 2008. It was amusing to hear the children shouting out answers, often several at once, sounding almost like a chorus.

Shortly before the show began, a man came out and tossed roughly a dozen large, glowing, multicolored light sticks into the audience, seemingly aiming them toward the children, who were understandably delighted.

Then a countdown appeared on the screen. I was busy preparing my notebook to take notes, so when I first looked up, it was already at 2:16. As the clock ticked down, the excitement in the theater grew increasingly palpable. When it reached the final minute, the kids began shouting out the numbers, becoming especially enthusiastic during the final 20 seconds. By the time the countdown reached zero, they were practically beside themselves with excitement.

Taylorville opened with “Cruel Summer,” the first of three consecutive songs from Swift’s Lover album. Lead singer Sinead Angele appeared in a glittery silver outfit, while powerful blasts of white vapor shot straight up from the stage. These cryo jets were so powerful that I could actually feel the cold air from my fifth-row seat.

“You Need to Calm Down” and “The Man” followed, the latter featuring Angele in a gold-and-silver dress. During “The Man,” machines released hundreds of unusual white bubbles that looked like perfectly shaped little orbs. When touched, they burst into tiny clouds of smoke. I’d never encountered these particular special effects before, and the children absolutely loved them. I must admit that I had some fun popping a few myself.

The band then moved into Swift’s earlier material with “Love Story,” “You Belong With Me,” and “Should’ve Said No.” One thing I particularly appreciated about Taylorville was that they weren’t afraid to reinterpret the songs, often giving them a harder, more rock-oriented sound. Even the country-era material sounded more like the pop remixes of those songs, only with heavier guitars. In fact, there were moments when Taylorville sounded more like a rock band than a pop act.

During “Should’ve Said No,” the video screen displayed images of the moon while Angele wore a yellow dress with a green hood. The outfit reminded me somewhat of Little Red Riding Hood.

Next came “willow” and “’tis the damn season,” both from evermore. Interestingly, “willow” was one of the few songs that didn’t seem to excite the young audience quite as much as the others. Several children near me actually sat down during the performance, which was practically unheard of for the rest of the show. Fortunately, another barrage of smoke-filled bubbles quickly restored their enthusiasm.

The Midnights portion of the concert featured “Bejeweled” and “Karma,” two of my favorite songs from that album. During “Bejeweled,” the video screen was filled with images of candles and diamonds. Lots and lots of diamonds.

When Angele sang the line “Baby boy, I think I’ve been too good of a girl,” I was struck by how much of her performance involved adopting Taylor’s flirtatious stage persona. There was something about the way she delivered certain lyrics, smiled, and made eye contact with the audience that reminded me remarkably of Swift herself.

Interestingly, bassist Chuck Williams switched to a second keyboard for “Bejeweled,” apparently playing the bass parts on the keyboard instead of his usual instrument.

The visuals for “Karma” were somewhat unusual, featuring a little white ball floating around flowers. There were also plenty more bubbles, much to the children’s delight.

From there, Taylorville tackled some of Swift’s more recent material, including “Elizabeth Taylor,” “The Fate of Ophelia,” and “Opalite” from The Life of a Showgirl. Angele wore a striking red lingerie-inspired outfit, complete with a garter belt and gloves, during “Elizabeth Taylor,” while gold stars filled the video screen.

“The Fate of Ophelia” received an especially hard-rocking arrangement, and the kids went absolutely crazy. They were jumping up and down so enthusiastically that I could actually feel my seat shaking beneath me. That was one of several moments when I was reminded just how much energy a theater full of young Swifties can generate.

Of course, I was especially excited when the band launched into the Reputation material. That’s my favorite Taylor Swift album, and Taylorville performed three songs from it: “…Ready for It?,” “Look What You Made Me Do,” and “Don’t Blame Me.”

These songs were particularly well suited to the band’s harder-edged approach. Guitarist Thomas Butler was especially impressive during “Don’t Blame Me,” delivering an excellent solo that included some flashy whammy-bar work. It was one of several occasions when his playing elevated the performance beyond what you might expect from a typical tribute act.

The next portion of the show featured three selections from The Tortured Poets Department: “Who’s Afraid of Little Old Me?,” “But Daddy I Love Him,” and “I Can Do It With a Broken Heart.”

“But Daddy I Love Him” was another song during which the kids seemed slightly less enthusiastic, but Butler compensated with a terrific guitar solo. He was really shredding on that one, and I thoroughly enjoyed it.

I was also curious whether Angele would sing the profanity in “I Can Do It With a Broken Heart,” given how many young children were in attendance. But when she reached the line “I can handle my shit,” she sang it exactly as written.

Throughout the concert, Angele underwent an astonishing number of costume changes, sometimes changing outfits after only a song or two. I don’t know whether all of her costumes were modeled on outfits Taylor Swift has actually worn, but most certainly looked like the sort of things you’d see on the Eras Tour.

What impressed me almost as much as the outfits themselves was how quickly she managed to change into them. Sometimes she would leave the stage as soon as she’d finished singing her final lines, allowing the musicians to finish the song while she changed backstage. I don’t think even Taylor herself could have changed costumes much faster.

During some of these brief absences, the children began chanting “Taylor! Taylor! Taylor!” Apparently, they were completely caught up in the illusion.

At one point, I overheard a mother trying to explain to her child, who looked about four or five years old, that the woman onstage wasn’t actually Taylor Swift but someone performing her songs. The child didn’t seem to understand the distinction. It made me wonder how many other young children genuinely believed they were seeing Taylor herself.

In fact, Angele’s resemblance to Swift was sometimes almost uncanny. Not only did she look and sound remarkably like her, she also recreated many of her dance moves and mannerisms, shaking her hips, dancing around the stage, and flashing those familiar smiles. She even had that distinctive way Taylor sometimes flirts with her eyes while performing.

I couldn’t help thinking that Angele must have studied countless hours of Taylor Swift concert footage. Her performance seemed almost as much an acting role as a singing gig. She wasn’t merely trying to reproduce Taylor’s vocals; she was trying to embody her entire stage persona. And she was remarkably successful.

As impressive as Angele was, the musicians behind her deserve plenty of credit, too. Bassist Chuck Williams and drummer Jeffrey Hall formed a tight, reliable rhythm section, while Brian Porter’s keyboards added texture and color to the arrangements. Porter also serves as the band’s musical director, and I would imagine he plays a significant role in developing their distinctive sound. But guitarist Thomas Butler was the instrumental standout for me. His impressive solos, particularly during “Don’t Blame Me” and “But Daddy I Love Him,” were among the musical highlights of the show.

The concert’s final stretch was devoted largely to crowd-pleasing hits, including “22,” “We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together,” “Style,” “Blank Space,” and “Shake It Off.”

During “We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together,” the band unleashed roughly a dozen enormous pink balloons into the audience. These were some of the biggest balloons I’ve ever seen at a concert, and the children went absolutely wild batting them around like beach balls.

Angele wore a sparkly red-and-green outfit during that song and “Style,” complete with mismatched boots—one red and the other green—which I found rather cute.

The balloons were so popular that they actually became something of a distraction. During “Style,” I’d estimate that perhaps a third of the children were more interested in bouncing the balloons around than watching the performance. Then the band released even more bubbles, giving the kids something else to occupy themselves with. Nevertheless, plenty of children continued singing along enthusiastically.

The special effects were an important part of the production throughout the evening. In addition to the cryo jets and enormous balloons, the smoke-filled bubbles appeared repeatedly, with some of the final bursts featuring pink, yellow, and blue bubbles rather than the white ones we’d seen earlier.

The concert concluded with “Shake It Off,” which Angele announced was the band’s favorite song to perform. Appropriately enough, streamers were unleashed during the song, adding one final visual flourish to an already spectacular production.

Afterward, Angele announced that she’d be doing a free meet-and-greet at the merchandise table in just a couple of minutes. She even said she was looking forward to trading friendship bracelets with the children. A little girl near me immediately reached into her pocket and pulled out several bracelets, clearly excited about the opportunity.

As I was leaving, there were already at least 50 children lined up to meet Angele, purchase merchandise, or both. Considering how much energy she’d expended singing, dancing, and constantly changing costumes, I was amazed that she was willing to spend what could easily be another hour or two interacting with her young fans. That kind of dedication deserves recognition.

But perhaps the biggest compliment I can pay Taylorville is that they made me want to see the real Taylor Swift in concert.

I’ve been a Taylor Swift fan since her early days, although I initially found her music a little too country for my tastes. I’ve enjoyed watching her evolve into a pop superstar, and I’ve come to love many of her albums, particularly Reputation, Red and Midnights. Nevertheless, I’d never seriously considered attending one of her concerts.

Part of the reason was that I found the Swifties a little intimidating. Some of her fans seem to know absolutely everything about her life, analyzing every lyric for Easter eggs and discussing her relationships and career in astonishing detail. I suppose I felt that I wasn’t quite enough of a die-hard fan to insert myself into that environment.

I was also concerned that I’d feel out of place as an older adult surrounded by teenagers and children.

But sitting there in the fifth row at Taylorville, surrounded by hundreds of excited little kids, I found myself singing along to song after song and having an absolutely wonderful time. And I realized that it really didn’t matter how old I was or how much trivia I knew about Taylor’s personal life. I loved the songs, and that was enough.

Besides, plenty of parents were singing along enthusiastically, too. I noticed a few who looked as though they’d rather have been somewhere else, but most seemed to be enjoying themselves almost as much as their children.

Ultimately, Taylorville succeeded in doing something rather remarkable: they recreated much of the excitement and spectacle of a major Taylor Swift concert in a relatively intimate theater. Between the excellent musicianship, the elaborate costumes, the impressive special effects, and Sinead Angele’s remarkably convincing performance, the show delivered far more than I expected from a tribute act.

And the fact that I left wanting to see Taylor Swift herself wasn’t because Taylorville had left me feeling that something was missing. Quite the opposite. They reminded me just how much I love Taylor Swift’s music and how exhilarating it can be to experience those songs with an audience that loves them just as much.

That’s about the highest compliment I can give a tribute act.


TAYLORVILLE SETLIST — NOVEMBER 15, 2026

  1. “Cruel Summer”
  2. “You Need to Calm Down”
  3. “The Man”
  4. “Love Story”
  5. “You Belong With Me”
  6. “Should’ve Said No”
  7. “willow”
  8. “’tis the damn season”
  9. “Bejeweled”
  10. “Karma”
  11. “Elizabeth Taylor”
  12. “The Fate of Ophelia”
  13. “Opalite”
  14. “…Ready for It?”
  15. “Look What You Made Me Do”
  16. “Don’t Blame Me”
  17. “Who’s Afraid of Little Old Me?”
  18. “But Daddy I Love Him”
  19. “I Can Do It With a Broken Heart”
  20. “22”
  21. “We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together”
  22. “Style”
  23. “Blank Space”
  24. “Shake It Off”

TAYLORVILLE LINEUP

  • Sinead Angele — Lead vocals (“Taylor”)
  • Chuck Williams — Bass, keyboards
  • Thomas Butler — Guitar
  • Jeffrey Hall — Drums
  • Brian Porter — Keyboards, musical director

Visit Taylorville on Instagram

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *